Paul M. Sherrill
Music Theorist

[ Home ]

[ Curriculum Vitae ]

[ Teaching ]

[ Links ]


Research

My research splits into two main subjects: mathematical music theory and eighteenth-century European vocal music.

Abstracts and Links for Articles & Book Chapters


2026 (accepted). “Bright notes, dark scales, and Debussy’s La fille aux cheveux de lin.” Journal of Mathematics and Music. (https://doi.org/10.1080/17459737.2026.2765778)

Abstract: Building on recent studies of musical scales, this article develops a theory of scale-degree brightness. It defines a sense in which each individual note of a scale can be relatively bright or dark. For instance, the leading tone is the brightest note of the standard major scale. This notion of scale-degree brightness unifies several related phenomena. First, it is closely related to notions of modal brightness: when a bright scale degree is taken as the tonic of a collection, a dark mode results (and vice versa). Second, scale-degree brightness is shown to be a suitable generalization of Hook (2023)’s spelled pitch-class numbers. This more general perspective reveals that spc numbers accord a less central role to the diatonic scale and the line of fifths than might first be assumed, although they do encode a bias toward heptachords more generally.

To demonstrate some uses of these ideas, the article ends with a substantial analysis of Claude Debussy’s piano prelude La fille aux cheveux de lin. While a contrast between pentatonic and diatonic scales has long been recognized as central to the piece, this analysis suggests that it also uses 3, 4, and 6-note collections as scales. Moreover, its scalar organization follows consistent patterns that can be described effectively in terms of brightness. The piece’s opening creates an ambiguity between two potential tonics, G♭ and E♭. Which of the two pitch classes is brighter depends on which scale they are embedded in. The piece tends to treat the brighter pitch as the more stable tonic. It reinforces that tendency with a differentiation of melodic shape. Each scale is strongly associated with lines that move in a particular way (ascending, descending, or undulating); brightness consistently predicts the direction of that association. These patterns suggest the potential rewards of analytical focus on scales, revealing a richly textured use of musical structures that might otherwise be easy to dismiss as rudimentary.

2026. “Symmetries of the Modal Color Theory Hyperplane Arrangements” in Mathematics and Computation in Music 2026, edited by Mariana Montiel, et al. Lecture Notes in Computer Science 16609. (Cham, Switzerland: Springer.) (https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-032-27827-2_5)

Abstract: This paper extends a model of scale structure proposed in Sherrill (2025). It offers a mathematical characterization of the hyperplane arrangements, Mn, at the center of that model. In particular, it defines for each arrangement a group of symmetries Pn that preserve the essential structure of the arrangement. Two scales that are related by a symmetry in Pn have important features in common, so the orbits of scales under the action of Pn on Mn define broad equivalence classes of scale structure. It is shown that all n-note scales which are non-degenerate well-formed belong to a single orbit and that pairwise well-formed n-note scales constitute a union of orbits. A sense in which the scales in an orbit have similar voice-leading characteristics is demonstrated. Finally, scale structures which are fixed points of elements in Pn are discussed, including an argument that symmetry under melodic inversion is a closely related phenomenon.

2026. “On Recitative Intrusions in Le nozze di Figaro” in Analyzing Mozart’s Operas, edited by Lauri Suurpää, John Koslovsky, Nathan John Martin. Analysis in Context: Leuven Studies in Musicology 8. (Leuven, Belgium: Peeters.) (Peeters Website)

Abstract: Because recitative is defined by a limited vocabulary of melodic formulas, musical moments can be recognized as being recitative-like even when they occur outside of recitative proper. That is, recitative can be used as a musical topic, with its stylistic features borrowed outside their normal habitat. This chapter analyzes how Mozart uses recitative this way throughout his opera Le nozze di Figaro, letting it intrude into the ongoing flow of the opera’s arias and ensembles. I argue that these moments of “recitative intrusion” create emotional and dramatic expression not purely through rhetorical or extroversive means, but also by affecting the unfolding of a number’s musical form. They disrupt or complicate the formal functions typical of Mozart’s instrumental and/or “songful” music. I demonstrate the analytical potential of this perspective through close readings of several numbers in the opera: the terzetto “Cosa sento!", the duettino “Cinque... dieci...”, the aria “Venite inginocchiatevi,” and the terzetto “Susanna or via sortite.”

2025. “Modal Color Theory.” Journal of Music Theory 99/1: 1–49. (https://doi.org/10.1215/00222909-11595194)

Abstract: This article develops a theory of scale structure based in continuous pitch space. It launches from an investigation of the properties of “modal brightness,” a widespread intuition that scales (or modes) with relatively high pitches are qualitatively “bright.” The structural features of the diatonic scale (e.g., Myhill's property) mean that its modes demonstrate this phenomenon in a straightforward way, but generalizing brightness to the modes of other scales reveals unforeseen complexity. To explain this behavior, as well as to generalize other scalar properties, the article develops a geometrical model of scalar structures. In this model, the continuous space in which the scales exist (as ordered sets of pitches) is divided by an arrangement of hyperplanes. These hyperplanes characterize small qualitative aspects of a scale's structure, such as whether its first step is larger than its second step. Collectively, the hyperplanes partition the space into discrete regions of qualitatively different scalar structures that the article calls “colors.” The article offers computational tools for exploring those spaces, especially for cardinalities 2 through 7, and presents examples of the new insights they offer into the structure of both familiar and novel scales.

2024. “A Thread of Recitative Ruffs: Schemas and Schenker’s Analysis of ‘Erbarm es Gott’” Music Theory Online 30/2. [co-authored with Matthew Boyle] (https://doi.org/10.30535/mto.30.2.1)

Abstract: This article presents a schema-driven analysis of the accompanied recitative “Erbarm es, Gott” from Johann Sebastian Bach’s St. Matthew Passion. Arguing that the scene is best understood in dialogue with the conventions of the Italianate “galant” style of eighteenth-century recitative, we suggest that the music is guided by a simple thread of modulation upward through the circle of fifths. This thread is driven by repeated application of a particular harmonic schema—the “ruff,” as described in Sherrill and Boyle (2015)—which prototypically displaces a consonant harmony with a ♯4 figure over a static bass. Tonal arrivals are repeatedly implied and then evaded, such that the recitative’s simple tonal thread is best understood in terms of events that do not actually occur. This interpretation counterpoints Heinrich Schenker’s analysis of the recitative in Der Tonwille, whose details are explored in conjunction with the schema-based perspective. The final portion of the article advances an expressive interpretation of the music, engaging also with scholarship on the Passion such as Chafe (1991). In our reading, the recitative’s tonal shape stages an experience of progressive engrossment in the diegetic world of the Passion, broken off by an abrupt narrative negation at its end.

2018. “Susanna’s ‘Deh vieni.’” Music Theory Online 24/4. (https://doi.org/10.30535/mto.24.4.5)

Abstract: This article offers an analysis of “Deh vieni non tardar,” Susanna’s last aria in Mozart’s Le nozze di Figaro . The aria stages a diegetic performance in which Susanna serenades an absent beloved while Figaro eavesdrops, but the aria is not simply a facsimile of Susanna’s performance. Instead, the music scripts a shift of the audience’s perspective, moving from a quasi-literal representation of the performance to a depiction of Susanna’s affective experience of performing. This shift in perspective realigns how different musical parameters collaborate to produce meaning.

Observations from disparate domains coalesce into an interpretation of the aria. The analysis engages with musical details by starting from hypotheses about what the piece is (serenade or psychologizing aria), what it does (deliver text or embody expressive action), and how its musical features afford those identities. The central analytical questions are what genre “Deh vieni” belongs to and how its features serve the functions of that genre.

2015. “Galant Recitative Schemas.” Journal of Music Theory 59/1: 1–62. [co-authored with Matthew Boyle] (https://doi.org/10.1215/00222909-2863382)

Abstract: Italianate recitative of the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries constituted a distinct musical language that coexisted with the familiar style of common practice music. In this article we propose a theory of that language (“galant recitative”), which we characterize in terms of a core vocabulary of fifteen melodic formulas. Appendix 1 presents a roster of these formulas, which captures a unique fingerprint of recitative, distinct from the comparable inventory of homophonic phrase schemas in Robert Gjerdingen’s Music in the Galant Style. These recitative schemas are defined in terms of characteristic melodic profiles, harmonic contexts, formal roles, and expressive associations. One representative schema, the “O cielo,” is used to demonstrate the musical features and range of variation characteristic of all recitative schemas. The formal associations of the schemas allow us to describe the basic phrase syntax of recitative, grouping the schemas into three broad formal roles: initiatory, medial, and closing. Appendix 2 demonstrates this formal model by analyzing the dramatic climax of Leonardo Vinci and Pietro Metastasio’s opera Artaserse (1730). Additionally, some schemas have focused semantic connotations and are used to mark such utterance types as questions and witticisms. The article concludes with an analysis of scenes from act 1 of Mozart’s Così fan tutte, which shows how sensitivity to manipulations of galant recitative schemas can reveal subtle effects of characterization and dramatic continuity.

Book Reviews


2025. Review of How Sonata Forms by Yoel Greenberg. (Oxford University Press, 2022.) In Journal of Music Theory 69/2, 353–366. (https://doi.org/10.1215/00222909-11931897)

2021. Review of The Oxford Handbook of Critical Concepts in Music Theory, edited by Alexander Rehding and Steven Rings. (Oxford University Press, 2019.) In Music Theory Online 27/1. [co-authored with Antares Boyle, Rebecca Leydon, and Jeffrey Swinkin] (https://doi.org/10.30535/mto.27.1.9)

2011. Review of Music in the Galant Style by Robert O. Gjerdingen. (Oxford University Press, 2007.) In Theory and Practice: Journal of the Music Theory Society of New York State 36, 225–235. (https://www.jstor.org/stable/41784513)

Selected Conference Presentation Materials


2026. “Chord–Voice Leading Duality.” Presented to the Society for Music Theory, November 5. (Earlier versions presented to EuroMAC 11, Barcelona, September 10; and Rocky Mountain Society for Music Theory, Tucson, March 28.)

PDF of conference handout

Prerecorded video of the presentation:

2025. “Two relics of the cadenza doppia.” Presented to the Northwestern University Music Theory and Cognition Colloquium. Evantson, February 6.

Compilation video of a half-cadence schema I’m interested in:

2024. “Form Follows Scalar Content in Arvo Pärt’s Fratres.” Presented to the Ninth International Conference on Music and Minimalism, Belgrade, May 30.

Animations for the presentation (without the talk itself):